Not sure what plan is right for you? Take Our Medicare Quiz

Request A Quote

2023 Medicare Cost Year Over Year Comparison

Speak to an advisor

866-MEDIGAP (633-4427)

TTY: Dial 711

Email Us

Medicare Enrollment Starts In...








Not sure what plan is right for you? Take Our Medicare Quiz

Comparison: Medicare Supplement (Medigap) Plans vs Medicare Advantage Plans

  • Medicare with Melissa

There are two types of plans: (1) Medicare Supplement (Medigap) Plans and (2) Medicare Advantage Plans.

Medicare Supplement (Medigap) Plans: 

These are offered by private insurance companies and approved by Medicare. There are 10 standardized plans

Medicare Advantage Plans: 

These are offered by private insurance companies and approved by Medicare. You will continue to pay your Part B premium to Medicare. With these plans, you give up Original Medicare (Part A and Part B) and the insurance company you choose will manage the plan for you.

The table below shows a high-level difference between a Medicare Supplement (Medigap) plan and a Medicare Advantage plan.

Comparison: Medicare Supplement (Medigap) Plans vs Medicare Advantage Plans

Medicare Supplement (Medigap) PlansMedicare Advantage (Part C) Plans
Doctors and HospitalsNo networks:  You can choose any doctor, hospital or facility in the United States that accepts Medicare. Networks:  You will normally be required to use doctors and hospitals in your network. 
Primary Care PhysicianUse any doctor that takes MedicareSome plans you may need to select a primary care physician.
Referral to a SpecialistNo referrals requiredHMO:  Referral is required on most plansPPO:  No referral required
Prior ApprovalNone requiredIt is important that you follow the plan’s rule, like getting prior approval for certain services.
NetworkNo network restrictions.  Coverage goes with you across the United States. You have network restrictions.  Emergency care is covered when you travel within the United States.
Prescription Drug CoveragePrescription drugs are not included.  Consider purchasing a Part D plan.Prescription drug coverage is included with most plans. 
Gym MembershipSome insurance companies do offer gym memberships for free or reduced fee.  Ask your agent to explain.Many plans do include gym membership.
Dental, Vision and HearingNoMany plans do offer basic dental, vision and hearing plans. 
Out of Pocket ExpensesPredictable out of pocket expenses.  These expenses are low to $0 (not including premium). Deductibles and copays.  You pay as you go.  There is a maximum out-of-pocket for each plan.
TravelCan travel anywhere in the United States.  International travel has a $50,000 lifetime maximum.There are Regional plans that may cover you in some states.  No International travel.  Review this option carefully if you travel. 
CostsYou pay a monthly premium based on age, gender, and zip code.  Out of pocket costs are limited. Low to $0 monthly premium.  When you use the services, you will pay copays and deductibles.  Again, this is more of a pay-as-you-go plan. 

Learn More: Should I stay with Original Medicare or Choose a Medicare Advantage Plan?

People Also Read: I have a Medicare Supplement (Medigap) plan, do I need a Medicare Advantage plan?

Popular Search:

Knee gel injections cost

When is the Medicare annual enrollment period?

Meet Melissa MacCalla

Medicare is not simple and can be hard, frustrating, and downright confusing for most. I love when I get someone on the phone and I am given the opportunity to explain the difference in plans to them and have Medicare make sense. I enjoy talking to clients year after year, hearing about their families growing or them asking about mine.


Oh my gosh!! I was so confused about the Medicare Supplement process. I am turning 65 soon and am retired and have always had insurance thru my former employer. I didn’t know a thing about going on Medicare and was struggling to sort it all out.

A friend of mine recommended contacting Senior HealthCare Solutions, so I did. Melissa was FANTASTIC!! She was professional, responsive, caring and friendly. She explained the steps I needed to take, gathered my information, helped me choose good plans for MY specific needs and took care of my applications over the phone. 1-2-3, eesy-peesy and I was done!! And it didn’t cost me a DIME!!! WOW!!! I HIGHLY recommend Senior Healthcare Solutions for anyone who’s overwhelmed with making the right choices with Medicare Supplemental Insurance and Rx coverage. It’ll take a load off your mind!

Janice W.

"*" indicates required fields

Get Help Now

Be sure to sign up and stay up to date on new articles and Medicare updates.
Zip Code*

🔒Your information is safe and secure.

You may unsubscribe from these communications at any time.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Excellent Rating

Have Questions? Want to Chat?

Use the link below to schedule an appointment with us.

Other posts you may interested in…

%d bloggers like this: